“Your lender choice might matter more than the house you choose. Here’s why, and what to do about it.”
Listen, I’m going to shoot straight with you: A 0.25% difference in your interest rate costs you approximately $15,000 on a $300,000 mortgage over 30 years. That’s a new car. That’s your kid’s first year of college. [1]
But here’s what’s even more critical in Ellis County and DFW right now: Speed kills. When five offers land on a property in Waxahachie or Midlothian within 24 hours, listing agents aren’t just looking at price. They’re looking at which buyer can actually close.
I’ve seen sellers accept offers $5,000-10,000 lower because one buyer had a lender with a track record and the other had… well, an adventure waiting to happen.
Your lender is your competitive advantage or your Achilles heel. Choose wisely.
Know Your Players: The North Texas Lender Landscape
Big Banks (Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo)
When they’re good: Great technology, relationship pricing for existing clients, handle jumbo loans easily.
Where they fall short: Cookie-cutter underwriting, slow centralized processing, underwriters in other states who’ve never heard of Ferris, Texas, and don’t understand why that development changes everything. They’re also impossible to get a hold of during an emergency or on the weekends. If something happens on a Saturday or Sunday, you’re not getting any help.
Bottom line: Decent if you’re W-2 employed with pristine credit buying a conventional property. Less ideal if you need flexibility, speed, strong communication, or local market understanding.
Credit Unions
Here’s what most agents won’t tell you: Credit unions often offer rates 0.25% to 0.5% lower than big banks. On a $350,000 mortgage, that’s $18,000-36,000 back in your pocket over 30 years.
Why they win: Not-for-profit structure, local decision-making, personalized service, often keep your loan instead of selling it.
The catch: Membership requirements (usually easy), fewer loan products, not 24/7 digital. Not only that the higher nationally so your agent could be in another state, and another time zone and they’re definitely not taking your calls on the weekends. No matter how much of an emergency it is.
Real talk: I’ve had buyers roll their eyes at credit union suggestions, until they saw rates half a point lower. Honestly, they were right to do so. I’ve seen quite a few credit unions torpedo deals because of their lack of organization and poor communication.
Online Lenders (Rocket Mortgage, Better.com)
What they do right: 24/7 access, fast processing, transparent rates, lower overhead can mean better deals.
Where to watch out: Complex situations don’t translate well to digital platforms, limited local market knowledge, less hand-holding for first-timers. They also are hit or miss on the quality of the agent you will get. Some agents are great, and some agents are just there to collect a paycheck. Unfortunately, there’s no way to select your agent, they are automatically assigned. Likely have zero experience with most homebuyer incentives in your state.
The Franklin perspective: Decent for straightforward deals with financially sophisticated buyers. Less ideal if you need education, have unique circumstances or need fast results.
Local Mortgage Companies
Why they’re powerful in our market:
- Know the local market, the ins and outs, and are very familiar with working with state level homebuyer incentives.
- Established relationships with local appraisers and title companies
- In-house underwriting means 14-21 day closings vs. 45-60 days
- Can actually solve problems with a phone call and we often take calls on weekends during emergencies
For most buyers, especially first-timers, local lenders are gold.
Mortgage Brokers
Shop your loan to multiple lenders. Can be great for unique situations.
Key question to ask: “How are you compensated? Are you recommending this lender because they’re best for me or because they pay you more?” Good brokers won’t flinch. Sketchy ones will.
The best bet is to find a local mortgage broker to get the best of both worlds.
My Strategic Lending Partners for Your Success
These aren’t paid referrals (that’s illegal). These are relationships I’ve built with professionals who’ve proven themselves in North Texas real estate. All three of these lenders have proven themselves time and time again with my clients. They’re very responsive, especially during emergencies.. There is no one I would trust more than these lenders. (click on their images to get started)
But here’s the deal: You should still shop rates. Compare these partners against 2-3 other lenders. If someone else beats them on rate and service, go for it. My goal isn’t to force you into one lane, it’s to make sure you have excellent options.
The Questions You Must Ask (No Exceptions)
About Rates and Costs
“What’s your interest rate AND your APR?”
The interest rate is what they advertise. The APR is what you actually pay when you include fees. A lender advertising 6.75% might have an APR of 7.1% because they’re loading fees. Another offering 6.875% might have an APR of 6.95%, making them actually cheaper.
If a lender gets squirrely when you ask about APR, walk.
“Can I lock this rate, and for how long?”
Rates change multiple times per day. A rate lock protects you. Standard locks are 30-60 days. Make sure the lock covers your closing date plus a buffer. [2]
“What are ALL your fees, and which are negotiable?”
Make them itemize everything: application fee, origination fee, processing fee, underwriting fee, admin fee. Then ask: “Which of these are negotiable?”
Here’s what most people don’t know: Almost all lender fees are negotiable. Especially if you have competing quotes. [3]
“Should I pay discount points?”
Discount points = prepaid interest. Each point costs 1% of your loan and typically reduces your rate by 0.25%.
Math: On a $300,000 loan, one point costs $3,000 and saves roughly $50/month. Break-even is 60 months.
Only makes sense if you’re keeping the loan past break-even. Most people move or refinance within 7-10 years.
About Process and Timeline
“How long does your process take, and what’s your on-time closing percentage?”
Average is 30-60 days. Good lenders with in-house underwriting can close in 14-21 days.
Ask for their closing stats from the last 90 days. Legit lenders will share. Sketchy ones deflect.
“What’s the difference between pre-qualification and pre-approval?”
Pre-qualification: Based on what you told them. No verification. Worthless in competitive markets.
Pre-approval: Verified income, assets, credit. Conditional approval subject to finding a property. This is what sellers want to see.
If anyone offers “instant pre-approval” without pulling credit, they’re lying.
“Will you service my loan or sell it?”
Some lenders keep your loan (continuity, accountability). Others sell servicing rights immediately (you’ll deal with a different company for payments).
Neither is automatically bad, but know what you’re getting.
About Communication
“Who is my single point of contact?”
You want ONE person who knows your file. Not a rotating cast who has to “look into it.”
The test: Email them a question after your initial meeting. How long does it take to respond? That’s your preview of the entire process.
“Can you provide references from recent clients?”
Good lenders will happily connect you. If they hesitate, that’s all the reference you need.
How to Actually Compare: The Loan Estimate
Federal law requires lenders to provide a standardized Loan Estimate within three business days of your application. Every lender uses the same format—this is your apples-to-apples comparison tool.
What to Compare:
Total Loan Costs (Page 2, Section D): All lender fees and charges. Focus on origination charges—these vary significantly and are often negotiable.
APR (Page 3): Best single number for comparing total cost. Includes interest and most fees.
Cash to Close (Page 3): Total you need at closing including down payment, closing costs, prepaid items, minus earnest money/seller credits.
Monthly Payment (Page 1): Compare the TOTAL monthly payment, not just principal and interest. Property taxes vary significantly between North Texas municipalities.
Quick Comparison Framework (Use this table to help you compare lenders)
| Lender | Interest Rate | APR | Monthly Payment | Closing Costs | Cash to Close |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lender 1 | |||||
| Lender 2 | |||||
| Lender 3 |
Plug in numbers from each Loan Estimate you receive. Now you can actually see differences.
Red Flags That Should Make You Run
Pressure tactics: “This rate is only available today.” Legitimate lenders don’t use artificial scarcity. But there’s a lot to be said for the fact that rates do change almost daily, especially in this market. Though they often don’t change much more than a 10th of a point.
Too-good-to-be-true rates: If one lender is 0.5%+ below everyone else, they’re either showing you a rate you don’t qualify for or baiting and switching.
Communication ghost: Takes days to respond now? Imagine during closing.
Fee fog: Can’t clearly explain every fee? You’re overpaying.
False pre-approval: Offers “pre-approval” without pulling credit? That’s pre-qualification. Sellers know the difference.
Changing story: Fees or rates that differ significantly from initial quotes without clear explanation.
Special North Texas Considerations
Local Market Knowledge Matters
Lenders who understand that new developments change everything can properly value properties in developing areas. National lenders using generic guidelines might undervalue your property, creating financing problems. This is why local lenders are almost always the better choice
Property Tax Reality Check
Texas has no state income tax, we make up for it in property taxes. Your lender MUST accurately estimate taxes for your specific property and taxing jurisdiction. I’ve seen $200-300/month underestimates that cause payment shock later.
Ask: “What property tax rate are you using, and is it specific to this property’s jurisdiction?”
Speed Wins Deals
In competitive neighborhoods, lender speed and reliability are competitive advantages. I’ve seen sellers accept lower offers because the buyer’s lender had a proven track record.
This is why I maintain strategic lender partnerships. When we submit an offer with one of my preferred lenders, listing agents know financing will close on schedule.
Avoiding First-Time Buyer Landmines
Landmine #1: Only talking to one lender. Even 0.125% difference saves thousands. Get three Loan Estimates minimum.
Landmine #2: Rate tunnel vision. Always compare APR, not just interest rate.
Landmine #3: House hunting without pre-approval. Sellers won’t take you seriously. Get pre-approved FIRST.
Landmine #4: Making financial moves during the process. No new credit cards, large purchases, job changes, or major deposits/withdrawals. Financial freeze from pre-approval to closing.
Landmine #5: Not reading documents. Read your Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure carefully. You have three business days before closing to review, use that time.
Landmine #6: Choosing based on relationships alone. Personal referrals are valuable but not sufficient. Still get competing quotes.
Landmine #7: Ignoring red flags. If they’re unresponsive now, it won’t improve. Choose someone else.
Your Action Plan
This Week:
Day 1-2: Identify 3-5 potential lenders (include my strategic partners in your comparison)
Day 3-4: Make initial contact, submit applications, ask your questions
Day 5-7: Compare Loan Estimates using the framework above
Next Week:
Choose your lender and get pre-approved. Submit all documentation promptly.
Throughout the Process:
- Respond immediately to lender requests
- Financial freeze – no major changes
- Keep your agent informed of progress
- Stay organized with all documents
The Bottom Line
The mortgage industry has operated on information asymmetry for decades. They win when you don’t compare, when you’re intimidated by the process.
You now have the information. You know the questions. You have the comparison framework.
This is your move.
Most buyers will read this, feel empowered for 15 minutes, then default to whoever called back first. Don’t be most buyers.
The difference between a strategic lender choice and a convenient one is tens of thousands of dollars and potentially the difference between closing on your dream home or watching someone else get it.
You’re not just choosing someone to lend you money. You’re selecting a strategic partner in one of the biggest financial decisions of your life.
Choose like your financial future depends on it.
Because it does.
Ready to talk strategy? I don’t just connect you with lenders—I help you navigate the entire homebuying process with the same strategic thinking that went into this guide.
This is chess, not checkers. Let’s play to win.
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial or legal advice. Mortgage rates and regulations change frequently. Always consult with licensed mortgage professionals and review current terms before making financial decisions.
Join The Discussion